A single insurance company’s disclosure problem highlighted in our August 28 note (Insurance: It's About Disclosure, Not Investment Quality) has subsequently surfaced questions about who is watching insurance industry disclosure. When we first flagged the issue in our note, it centered on investments held by insurance entities controlled by Guggenheim Partners co-founder and CEO Mark Walter that appear misclassified.
It now appears this example of misclassification has focused attention on the entire insurance industry. Last Friday, a letter drafted by Senator Elizabeth Warren pushed the classification question directly to the NAIC. The letter, addressed to NAIC CEO Jeffrey Johnston, asked the NAIC to explain how a misclassification of this size by the Walter-controlled entities went undetected under its current, state-based oversight.
As background, Delaware Life Insurance Co. and Clear Spring Life and Annuity Co.—the flagship insurance carriers of Group 1001, the holding company controlled by Walter—appear to have misclassified a large share of their investment portfolio holdings. The issue centers on loans and investments held by Walter-affiliated insurance entities that were not categorized as affiliated on statutory filings. FactSet data below lists holders of Dodger Tickets LLC as reported on Schedule D, including Delaware Life Insurance Co. Note the unaffiliated categorization of the holding.
Source: FactSet and AM Best. Sectors & Insights - FactSet
The magnitude of the classification discrepancy has helped fuel the outcry. Originally the entities reported affiliated investment exposure at 3%, which has since been restated to at least 39% of the insurance entities' invested assets, and by some accounts as high as 42%. Regulators are now examining the classification of the investments, not whether those investments were unsound.
This is not a solvency problem or an investment-quality problem. Consider the investment highlighted in our August 28 note, Dodger Tickets LLC. The Delaware Life entity is one of roughly two dozen insurance entities holding a position in Dodger Tickets LLC, according to the Schedule D data shown above. The list of holders seen with this link Sectors & Insights - FactSet can be surfaced using FactSet functionality.
This is a disclosure-classification problem, and that makes the issue applicable to any insurer with affiliated investment holdings, not just the Walter-controlled entities in our August 28 article. It is important to note that the investments themselves are not in question, nor are the other holders under scrutiny for owning them. Delaware Life's position in the Dodger Tickets LLC investment drew attention only because of Walter's common control over both the insurance entities and certain investments made by the entities, an affiliation that was not disclosed. However, every insurance entity that holds investments faces the same underlying question: are any related-party investment positions correctly flagged in financial statements, or does the gap exist but only surface when reviewed?
Walter and a rating agency have responded to the misclassification issue. Delaware Life and TWG Global executed a $6.5 billion asset exchange in mid-August, disclosed in Delaware Life's second-quarter statutory statement, to move the disputed holdings off the insurer's balance sheet. A rating agency subsequently downgraded its outlook, per trade press reporting.
That sequence, restate, swap, downgrade, is the outcome from this example. The two questions faced by the industry are whether new disclosure standards would be enough to prevent the issue and whether other insurers share similar affiliate structures and disclosure, which may prompt a similar unwind.
A response to Senator Warren's September 11 letter is due September 24. The NAIC has not indicated what, if any, exam or guidance activity is underway beyond confirming receipt of the letter, and no independent statement from the NAIC on the substance of the case has been made public.
That gap, a regulatory inquiry with a deadline but no visible response yet, is worth watching. The NAIC’s response will show whether this issue remains a single-company matter or becomes the catalyst for an industry-wide look at how affiliate transactions get classified on statutory statements.
None of this unwind means Group 1001 acted improperly, and no enforcement action has been announced. It's possible the September 24 response closes the loop with a straightforward disclosure fix. But the more consequential version of this story is the one where the NAIC's answer signals that other carriers with comparable related-party structures should expect the same scrutiny, the same restatement, and potentially the same forced unwind that Walter’s entities are now working through.
Macro summary
Payrolls rose +162,000 in August—the strongest print in five months—with June and July revised up a combined 55,000 and wages up 3.1% year-over-year, while the unemployment rate held at 4.1% for a second straight month and initial jobless claims fell to 196,000, comfortably below the 225,000 watch level.
Inflation sent a more mixed signal: headline CPI held flat at 3.4%, but core CPI reaccelerated to 0.3% month-over-month even as the annual core rate eased to 2.4% (lowest since 2021), and PPI jumped to 5.4% year-over-year, the fastest pace of this cycle. That combination of resilient hiring and firming producer-price pressure was enough to push the Federal Reserve into its first rate hike in three years on September 16, lifting the policy rate 25bp to 3.75%–4.00% and sending the 10-year Treasury to 5.00%, its highest since 2007, with equities selling off modestly on the decision (S&P -0.44%, Nasdaq roughly flat).
Insurance earnings implications
For life/annuity carriers, the rate hike and a 10-year yield above 5% are a clear tailwind—new money is being deployed at materially better reinvestment rates, supporting spread income even as equity-market volatility argues for near-term caution on variable annuity and asset-management fee income tied to AUM.
For P&C, August's payroll strength and low jobless claims point to continued exposure growth in commercial auto and workers' comp, but the reacceleration in core CPI and record-pace PPI signal that repair, medical, and materials cost pressure hasn't cleared the pipeline, keeping conservative loss-cost trend assumptions warranted heading into fourth-quarter rate filings and reserve reviews.
Our Macro Tracker table below lists key economic data and the potential impact on insurance company earnings. The right-hand column identifies the specific, potential impacts on company earnings.
PPI (Producer Price Index): Producer prices jumped 0.4% in August and 5.4% year-over-year, the fastest annual pace of this cycle, led by a 24.1% surge in diesel and broad-based increases in transportation and warehousing services.
Earnings implications: Accelerating upstream cost pressure—especially in fuel, freight, and materials—points to continued elevated claims severity for auto physical damage and property lines, reinforcing the case for conservative loss-cost trend assumptions in Q4 rate filings.
The S&P 500 fell 0.44% and the Nasdaq was essentially flat as the Fed delivered its first rate hike in three years, with Financials and Energy leading sector declines; the 10-year Treasury closed at 5.00%, its highest since 2007.
Earnings implications: Higher reinvestment yields are a tailwind for both P&C investment income and life/annuity spread businesses as new money is deployed at materially better rates, but the equity pullback and continued volatility argue for near-term caution on variable annuity and asset-management fee income tied to AUM.
Initial claims fell to 196K in the week ending September 12, down 10K and pulling the 4-week average to 203.25K, its lowest reading in over a month.
Earnings implications: Claims well below the 225K watch level point to continued labor-market resilience supportive of group life and disability persistency, though the gap to the still-elevated continuing-claims level (1.774M) bears watching for slower re-employment pressuring disability reserve adequacy.
The rate held at 4.1% for a second straight month, with the household survey showing both employment and the labor force expanding roughly in step.
Earnings implications: Stable joblessness alongside genuine employment growth (rather than a shrinking labor force) is a healthier signal for group benefits persistency and disability claims incidence than recent months, supporting steady in-force premium.
Payrolls rose +162K in August, the strongest month in five and well above the 56K trailing 12-month average, with June and July revised up a combined 55K.
Earnings implications: A reacceleration in hiring supports group life, disability, and workers' comp premium volume through a broader payroll base, though the sample remains volatile enough (three negative months over the past year) that carriers should avoid over-extrapolating a single strong print into pricing assumptions.
Initial claims fell to 196K in the week ending September 12, down 10K and pulling the 4-week average to 203.25K, its lowest reading in over a month.
Earnings implications: Claims well below the 225K watch level point to continued labor-market resilience supportive of group life and disability persistency, though the gap to the still-elevated continuing-claims level (1.774M) bears watching for slower re-employment pressuring disability reserve adequacy. \
The table directly below presents AUM roll forward data for PRU, EQH, and HIG from 2Q21 through 1Q26, individual company net change (as a percentage of beginning AUM), and S&P 500 quarterly price return. The pattern that emerges is both consistent and actionable: AUM balances follow S&P 500 returns.
Updated company AUM data for Equitable and Voya show increases in AUM. This result is expected given the equity market data we tracked throughout 2Q.
Equitable (up): Company/Security - Assets Under Management - EQH-US - FactSet
Hartford (drop): Company/Security - Assets Under Management - HIG-US
Principal (up): Company/Security - Operations by LOB - FactSet
Voya (up): Company/Security - Assets Under Management - FactSet
Manulife (up): Company/Security - Assets Under Management - FactSet
FactSet Insight blog: Read more insurance sector analysis in our previous blog articles.
Document search: Access insurance insight reports from the FactSet Workstation using the Document Search function. Search for "Insurance Tracker: Event of the Week".
Today’s Top News: Insurance insight reports are also delivered on the Workstation through StreetAccount’s Today’s Top News, or “TTN”. Aside from providing access to insight reports, TTN provides an insurance-focused daily sector synopsis, updated events calendar, and “insurance reads” that highlight current news stories that impact the insurance sector.
To access TTN, select the Today’s Top News tab on the FactSet Workstation and select Insurance from the drop-down menu (both highlighted below).
Deep sector data and functionality shown in this report are available through the FactSet Workstation. Learn more about FactSet insurance solutions that combine investment research, portfolio construction, and risk management in a cloud-native platform. Our comprehensive tools enable investment and actuarial teams to enhance asset modeling and capitalize on market opportunities.
This blog post is for informational purposes only. The information contained in this blog post is not legal, tax, or investment advice. FactSet does not endorse or recommend any investments and assumes no liability for any consequence relating directly or indirectly to any action or inaction taken based on the information contained in this article.