The Q2 2026 P&C earnings cycle read, on paper, like a good quarter. Combined ratios improved. Reserves released favorably. Investment income hit records. By the numbers institutional investors check first, casualty pricing looks fine. But combined ratios are backward looking. A capital-allocation decision is forward-looking. Chubb's decision to buy more reinsurance in a soft market could be the clearest signal of casualty rate inadequacy than any carrier's combined ratio disclosure this quarter.
Chubb posted an 83.8% combined ratio, which improved 1.8 points year over year. On its face, that argues casualty pricing is fine. CEO Evan Greenberg's own words on the July 22 call argue otherwise, and the point for our clients is that Chubb's reinsurance purchase may signal that the hard market is softening.
Asked about buying reinsurance, Greenberg said Chubb is doing it because "if there's a hungry market, at times it irrationally makes sense to us to feed the hungry." Reinsurers compete for new business in a soft reinsurance market, which means cheap pricing. So Chubb's comment indicates it is buying protection while reinsurance is inexpensive, a view that its own loss costs may climb faster than higher market pricing can absorb.
Chubb's U.S. primary casualty loss costs are running 6% to 7% annually, excess casualty 9.5% to 12%, but competitive pressure limits how much it can pass through in rate increases. The widening gap between rising loss costs and premium rates rising at a slower rate erodes underwriting margin quarter after quarter, even while the combined ratio still looks fine today.
Chubb's combined ratio result reflects business already on the books. Its reinsurance purchasing signals where management expects loss-cost trend to go next—a more useful read on longer-term profitability than combined ratio results.
Our message to clients is to listen for reinsurance purchasing on upcoming calls. By the time combined ratios are reported, the direction of profitability has already been determined.
Chubb Ltd.
Reinsurance exhibit: Schedule F
Schedule F's Ceded Reinsurance exhibit offers a way to check the longer-term direction of qualitative signals (such as those given on Chubb’s conference call) against the statutory record. Federal Insurance Company, Chubb's primary U.S. P&C underwriting entity is highlighted below in FactSet’s groups and subsidiaries exhibit.
As shown on Federal Insurance Co.’s Schedule F, the entity reported reinsurance premiums ceded of $15,450 million in 2025, up from $14,213 million the prior year. The Schedule F figures are company-disclosed data points, not management characterization, and provide a direct read on whether Chubb's actual, longer-term cession activity has been moving in the direction Greenberg's comments imply.
Macro summary
This week's data captured a market whipsawed by the Fed while the underlying economy kept sending mixed signals. Inflation held steady from two weeks ago—CPI at 3.5% headline, 2.6% core—while June PCE eased to 3.7%/3.3%, the first co-deceleration with CPI in five months, though core PCE stays stickier than core CPI.
Labor data was mixed: June payrolls rose just 57K after a 74K combined downward revision, and unemployment's dip to 4.2% was participation-driven rather than hiring-driven, even as the 4-week jobless claims average fell to 202.75K, its lowest since January 2024.
Equity markets saw the sharpest move: the S&P 500 and Nasdaq sold off 1.52% and 1.74% on July 29 after the Fed held rates with three dissents favoring a hike, before rebounding intraday on Microsoft's earnings.
Insurance earnings implications
The inflation and labor backdrop remains a mixed bag for underwriting: flat core CPI and sticky core PCE argue for continued caution on casualty and medical-cost reserve assumptions, while decelerating-but-positive labor data keeps group life, disability, and workers' comp trends stable rather than strengthening.
The bigger swing factor is equities. A sustained Fed-driven selloff would compress Q3 AUM-based fee income at annuity-heavy names (PRU, EQH) more than it dents already-reported Q2 results, and it typically nudges annuity sales mix toward fixed products. That is worth flagging given the rebound is still intraday.
Our Macro Tracker table below lists key economic data and the potential impact on insurance company earnings. The right-hand column identifies the specific, potential impacts on company earnings.
Inflation
June PCE eased to 3.7% headline (from 4.1%) and 3.3% core (from 3.4%), the first co-deceleration with CPI in five months, though core PCE remains well above the Fed's 2% target and above core CPI.
Earnings implications
The persistent core PCE to core CPI gap signals stickier services inflation, which matters for long-tail casualty reserving where the medical and legal cost trend is typically benchmarked closer to PCE-style services inflation than to headline CPI.
Equity markets
The S&P 500 and Nasdaq sold off 1.52% and 1.74%, respectively, on July 29 after the Fed held rates with three dissents favoring a hike. The Nasdaq closed over 10% off its record. Both are rebounding intraday today on Microsoft's earnings, though no new close is final yet.
Earnings implications
The drawdown compresses AUM-based fee income and separate account balances for insurers with annuity and asset-management arms, and continued volatility argues for caution on near-term fee guidance and a possible mix shift back toward fixed annuity products.
Unemployment
The rate eased to 4.2% in June from 4.3% in May, but the decline was driven by a sharp drop in labor force participation rather than net hiring.
Earnings implications
Because the improvement isn't hiring-led, disability claims incidence and group benefits persistency should hold steady near-term rather than genuinely strengthen; a further participation-rate slide would warrant a closer look at disability reserve adequacy.
Nonfarm payrolls
June payrolls rose just +57K, the weakest of four months, after April and May were revised down a combined 74K to +148K and +129K.
Earnings implications
Softening job growth points to slower group life and disability premium growth as employer headcounts stall, and a thinner payroll base also dampens workers' comp exposure growth at carriers with large commercial books.
Weekly jobless claims
Initial claims for the week ending July 25 rose 9K to 197K (prior week revised up from 187K to 188K), but the 4-week average fell to 202.75K, its lowest since January 2024.
Earnings implications
The still-declining trend average supports continued group disability and life persistency, though the divergence between low initial filings and rising continuing claims bears watching for slower re-employment pressuring disability reserve adequacy.
The table directly below presents AUM roll forward data for PRU, EQH, and HIG from 2Q21 through 1Q26, individual company net change (as a percentage of beginning AUM), and S&P 500 quarterly price return. The pattern that emerges is both consistent and actionable: AUM balances follow S&P 500 returns.
Equitable (drop): Company/Security - Assets Under Management - EQH-US - FactSet
Hartford (drop): Company/Security - Assets Under Management - HIG-US
Prudential (drop): Company/Security - Assets Under Management - FactSet
Principal: Company/Security - Operations by LOB - FactSet
Voya (drop): Company/Security - Assets Under Management - FactSet
Manulife (drop): Company/Security - Assets Under Management - FactSet
FactSet Insight blog: Read more insurance sector analysis in our previous blog articles.
Document search: Access insurance insight reports from the FactSet Workstation using the Document Search function. Search for "Insurance Tracker: Event of the Week".
Today’s Top News: Insurance insight reports are also delivered on the Workstation through StreetAccount’s Today’s Top News, or “TTN”. Aside from providing access to insight reports, TTN provides an insurance-focused daily sector synopsis, updated events calendar, and “insurance reads” that highlight current news stories that impact the insurance sector.
To access TTN, select the Today’s Top News tab on the FactSet Workstation and select Insurance from the drop-down menu (both highlighted below).
Deep sector data and functionality shown in this report are available through the FactSet Workstation. Learn more about FactSet insurance solutions that combine investment research, portfolio construction, and risk management in a cloud-native platform. Our comprehensive tools enable investment and actuarial teams to enhance asset modeling and capitalize on market opportunities.
This blog post is for informational purposes only. The information contained in this blog post is not legal, tax, or investment advice. FactSet does not endorse or recommend any investments and assumes no liability for any consequence relating directly or indirectly to any action or inaction taken based on the information contained in this article.