Texas regulators are deliberating on whether to approve the state’s first 765 kV transmission lines: five proposed projects totaling roughly 1,200 miles with an estimated cost of $11B, designed to carry power from the state’s other regions into the Permian Basin. The Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT) has so far acted on these applications in three groups, known as import paths.
It approved both Oncor projects on Import Path 1 (Dinosaur to Longshore and Longshore to Drill Hole) on August 28 and the AEP Texas and CPS Energy project on Import Path 3 (Howard to Solstice) on September 11. It has not decided the other two Oncor and LCRA projects on Import Path 2 (Bell County East to Big Hill and Big Hill to Sand Lake). Administrative Law Judges (ALJs) have recommended denying both, and the Commission sent the cases back to the judges for further findings rather than accept or reject that recommendation.
None of these recommendations is yet final. On November 12, the Commission voted not to take up rehearing motions on both Import Path 1 projects, which leaves those approvals on track to become final while rehearing motions on Import Path 3 remain pending.
The projects have drawn intense opposition from landowners and criticism from officials of both parties, and the larger uncertainty is now the 2027 legislative session. The November 3 election replaced the governor and lieutenant governor and shifted the Texas House majority to Democrats while Republicans kept the Senate, so a divided Legislature will convene in January with the power to reshape how or whether the build-out proceeds.
Each of the five projects is the subject of a certificate of convenience and necessity (CCN) application filed by Oncor Electric Delivery, LCRA Transmission Services, AEP Texas, or CPS Energy. Together they form three import paths to carry power from generation-rich parts of the state into a region ERCOT has identified as having substantial load growth but very little local generation of its own.
Figure 1 details the status and geography of each of these proposed projects. A detailed map can also be seen in our previously written analysis, New Transmission’s Role Amid U.S. Electricity Market Expansion.
Figure 1: Status of Permian Basin Reliability Projects
Both proceedings for Import Path 2 remain unresolved. On August 20, 2026, the ALJs assigned to Docket No. 59475 issued a Proposal for Decision (PFD) recommending the Commission deny both the Bell County East–Big Hill project and its companion Big Hill–Sand Lake project (Docket No. 59182, consolidated with 59475 on the question of need).
The ALJs found the applicants had not adequately substantiated the load forecast underlying the projects, had not shown that sufficient generation would be available in Central Texas to serve as a source for the westward power transfer, and had failed to provide required public-meeting notice to approximately 1,400 landowners (an independent basis for denial in its own right).
In a memorandum circulated September 9, 2026, Commission Chairman Thomas Gleeson concluded the PFD was incomplete, stating it had not addressed two issues the Commission's March 30, 2026, preliminary order directed the ALJs to resolve: whether the projects are necessary to meet state or federal reliability standards, and what congestion cost savings they might provide to consumers.
At its September 11 meeting, the Commission remanded both dockets to the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) to address those questions. That defers any decision on need and, by extension, on the ALJs' denial recommendation until the ALJs issue a supplemental PFD. The Commission has not indicated when that might occur.
The proceedings are unfolding alongside two related controversies.
The first is a rapidly intensifying statewide debate over large-load growth, particularly data centers and cryptocurrency mining. In June 2026, Governor Abbott directed the PUCT and ERCOT to ensure data centers and other large loads fund their own interconnection costs rather than shifting them to residential ratepayers, and he has since halted new data center grid connections pending an audit.
Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa, who defeated Abbott on November 3, said Texas will have laws to protect residents and that data center expansion should stop until laws are enacted, so the direction of travel continues through the change in administration.
ERCOT’s “Batch Zero” large-load study now requires developers to substantiate projected demand through notarized attestations, with a report due in December 2026. That effort reflects the same concern behind the Import Path 2 PFD: that ERCOT’s load-growth figures have included a substantial share of unconfirmed demand, and that regulators should tighten the evidentiary standards used to justify major infrastructure built on those figures.
The second controversy is landowner opposition to the 765 kV transmission lines, a significant political issue independent of the load forecast. Beyond the notice violations found in the 59475 PFD, farmers, ranchers, and rural landowners across the affected counties have raised concerns about permanent effects on agricultural land, property values, and the time and information provided to participate in the CCN process.
The criticism has crossed party lines. Before the election, outgoing Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick, Attorney General Ken Paxton, more than 30 members of the Texas House, and several senators asked the Commission to pause or deny further approvals until the Legislature could act. Republican Senator Charles Schwertner called for denying all pending applications, and Hinojosa campaigned on the principle that the state cannot trample property owners’ rights to build 765 kV lines “in record time.” Some legislators, including the House author of HB 5066, have said the 765 kV build-out exceeds what the Legislature intended to authorize in 2023.
The legal and regulatory framework for all five dockets traces back to House Bill 5066, signed into law in June 2023. The Legislature passed HB 5066 out of concern that ERCOT's existing transmission-planning process was too reactive and that new large loads—particularly in oil-and-gas and industrial areas—often weren't incorporated into planning until they had posted financial security, too late to support transmission projects with multi-year development timelines.
The law directed the PUCT to require ERCOT to identify regions where existing transmission capacity is insufficient to serve current and forecasted load and to develop a reliability plan for each region, specifically requiring a Permian Basin reliability plan addressing mineral-resource areas, forecasted load growth, and interconnection delays. The law also directed the Commission to issue a final order on transmission line CCNs no later than 180 days after the application is filed.
The costs in Figure 2 below are drawn from each docket's Proposal for Decision, which separately itemizes the transmission-line construction cost and the associated substation (“station work”) cost. Figures are stated in millions of dollars. Where a PFD provided a cost range rather than a single figure for the approved or recommended route, the midpoint of that range is used.
Figure 2: Estimated Cost of Permian Basin Reliability Projects
Whether these projects proceed carries direct financial consequences for the state's investor-owned utilities. Transmission investment approved through the CCN process is added to a utility's rate base, the pool of assets on which regulators permit it to earn a return, so approval of the Permian Basin projects translates into future earnings growth for the parent companies involved. Of the applicants on the five dockets:
Oncor (a subsidiary of Sempra) and AEP Texas are investor-owned and stand to benefit from rate-base growth if their respective projects are approved.
LCRA Transmission Services and CPS Energy, by contrast, are municipally owned utilities, so the earnings growth dynamic does not apply to their share of the investment.
CenterPoint Energy Houston Electric, another major investor-owned Texas utility, does not appear as an applicant on any of the five Permian-facing dockets, likely reflecting that its service territory lies well south and east of the Permian import paths.
Shares of the most exposed utilities have traded weaker amid investor concern that the ultimate scope of approved Texas transmission investment could come in smaller than previously anticipated.
Commission approval may not be the last word on how or whether these projects are built. The Legislature convenes January 12, 2027, with a Democratic House, a Republican Senate, and a new governor and lieutenant governor. Members of both parties have criticized the Commission’s handling of the dockets, and the governor-elect has said she will push for data center laws while promising a bipartisan transition.
The Legislature is not bound by the Commission’s decisions, and any bill must clear both chambers. Lawmakers’ could respond by leaving the approvals undisturbed, targeting adjustments such as stronger landowner notice and participation requirements or different cost-recovery conditions, or more fundamental changes in how such lines are approved.
ERCOT has reported unprecedented load growth in the Permian, and the problem HB 5066 was meant to address has not gone away, so the region will likely need additional transmission or generation in some form. The Commission’s time to act on the rehearing motions will run out by the end of December, while Import Path 2 remains in remand with no announced date for a response from the ALJs.
This blog post is for informational purposes only. The information contained in this blog post is not legal, tax, or investment advice. FactSet does not endorse or recommend any investments and assumes no liability for any consequence relating directly or indirectly to any action or inaction taken based on the information contained in this article.